P25RX Firmware Updates / Testing

Status
Not open for further replies.

goldmyne99

Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2018
Messages
274
Perhaps in a future release a RID "range" or a "wildcard" entry could be allowed in the alias tab?

Example: City A has 25 RIDs between 8100200 and 8100224. A wildcard entry of 81002?? Instead of entering all 25 RIDs.
 

daviddehaney

Newbie
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jul 2, 2006
Messages
4
Good evening all. Was wondering if P25RX can play audio for 2 different talk groups (one talk group on left speaker and another talk group on right speaker) like how SDRTrunk does when P25RX is connected to laptop USB or if it do that over Bluetooth?
 

goldmyne99

Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2018
Messages
274
Good evening all. Was wondering if P25RX can play audio for 2 different talk groups (one talk group on left speaker and another talk group on right speaker) like how SDRTrunk does when P25RX is connected to laptop USB or if it do that over Bluetooth?

I believe the P25RX currently is mono only.
I really enjoy the stereo priority feature in sdrtrunk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: btt

btt

Jew lover
Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
2,585
Location
Wa State
Good evening all. Was wondering if P25RX can play audio for 2 different talk groups (one talk group on left speaker and another talk group on right speaker) like how SDRTrunk does when P25RX is connected to laptop USB or if it do that over Bluetooth?
Yes, I made note of this as a desired feature for TDMA systems. I plan on adding support for this at some point, but it is not currently a high priority. This is much closer to being possible with the latest updates to the firmware.
 

btt

Jew lover
Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
2,585
Location
Wa State
Tried this newest updated version. It definitely runs smoother with the row highlighting off. It isnt really an issue, but a minor addition that would increase usablity for the alias screen would be sorting the columns. It wouldn't need to auto-sort in realtime as entries were added, which would make entries difficult, but if you could just double click the column name and have it sort according to column specified, like how the talkgroup screen does, would be sufficient.

Other than that, great job on the newest release! Adding RID's and aliases is another major addition to a great product.
The sorting was a great idea. It is much easier to edit now. Thanks for the suggestion!
----------------------
I have verified that the issue with the Alias tab becoming sluggish/unresponsive after hours of operation is fixed. 2021-02-23_1415 is now the new stable version. A new page for "firmware history" has been created. I will attempt to keep the details of changes there from here on out.
 

nosig55

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2007
Messages
172
Location
NEKS/NWMO & SWMO
The 2021-02-21_1144 did not work well for me. The audio was very choppy. Just updated to 2021-02-23_1415, audio is very good and scanning.
Is it possible to have more than one DMR conventional frequency entered ?
 

btt

Jew lover
Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
2,585
Location
Wa State
There were issues with all versions that have the Alias tab prior to the new stable version ( 2021-02-23_1415). The issue was causing choppy audio for BTConfig playback. The other issue of BLKS/SEC dropping to 0 without recovering appears to be fixed as well. Everyone should upgrade to the latest version.

There is no support for multiple DMR frequencies yet. I hoped to make more progress on the scanning by now, but getting the bugs fixed was a higher priority.
 

nosig55

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2007
Messages
172
Location
NEKS/NWMO & SWMO
There were issues with all versions that have the Alias tab prior to the new stable version ( 2021-02-23_1415). The issue was causing choppy audio for BTConfig playback. The other issue of BLKS/SEC dropping to 0 without recovering appears to be fixed as well. Everyone should upgrade to the latest version.

There is no support for multiple DMR frequencies yet. I hoped to make more progress on the scanning by now, but getting the bugs fixed was a higher priority.
@btt When I travel to SW Missouri, there is a about 6 DMR conventional that PD & Fire uses in the area. As long as one works it's fine. It is working really good now on what I listen to up north in KS. Thanks for all your support !!
 
  • Like
Reactions: btt

btt

Jew lover
Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
2,585
Location
Wa State
@btt is 1415 up on the site?
I was making some changes. I decided to add a couple of minor changes to the "stable" release, now 2021-02-24_1047. The link to _1415 is now listed as "previous stable". The main reason I decided to make a last minute change before shipping more radios is because I realized why at least one person was having a difficult time with the last batch shipped. In the SearchDB tab, the "test selected frequencies" and "use selected frequency as primary" buttons would be disabled in some states where they shouldn't be. They are always enabled now.
 

Mike_G_D

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
1,244
Location
Vista, CA
Hi Todd,

I know it has been a long time since I last reported in - been busy both in terms of work and personal life; even so, I have tried to follow your new versions and keep updated.

I regret to say that my long standing issue of "talk group bleedthru" is still occuring in the system I monitor and, until recently, it was extremely frustrating for me because I could not find some kind of pattern associated with it's occurance that may assist you in solving the issue, BUT I MAY finally have an observation that may help you investigate this issue!

I usually only keep the "Talk Group Log" screen up as I find the Console too "busy" and distracting for me while I am working. Unfortunately, the Talk Group Log screen does not show whether the received signal is P1 or P2 and, as you may recall, the system I listen to is a P25 P1 and P2 system with most Talk Groups being P1 but with a growing number of P2 talk groups in the mix.

What I have started to notice most recently is that, if I am looking at the Console screen when I get the "bleedthru" issue is that it seems like it is happening to P2 talk groups with P1 audio from other talk groups leaking thru. I think I would have seen this earlier if I could have seen that the TG was being received as P1 or P2 in the Talk Group Log screen.

When I now watch the Console screen and see and hear this issue happening it now looks like while the P2 TG is active and a conversation is taking place, in between gaps in the conversation I will hear audio from a completely different P1 TG. I am now seeing that, at least sometimes when this occurs, I see the Console data suddenly shift to showing P1 and then switch rapidly back to P2 when the original "correct" conversation continues. Sometimes, the P1 interfering traffic may last long enough to cause the desired P2 TG reception to miss occasional replies but often the P1 interfering traffic will abruptly cease when a reply comes back on the desired P2 TG.

I am not sure but it looks like the P2 traffic is subject to "interference" from the P1 traffic (which, on this system, still comprises the majority of the traffic) and may be more pronounced during busy periods (which would make sense). Maybe when the P1 "interference" causes the missing of replies during a P2 TG conversation it might be because the reply was on another time slot in the P2 transmission? That is just conjecture as I can't tell which slot the P2 traffic is carried on, of course.

Assuming that the above observation is correct (P1 traffic bleeding thru into P2 traffic), then I am guessing that if one is monitoring a pure P2 system with no mixing of P1 TG's or a pure P1 system with no mixing of P2 TG's this issue would never show itself.

Also to add - I do not use Priority at all and they are all set to 1; the issue occurs even in standalone mode - just noticed that today as it was obvious to my ear; it happens regardless of whether or not I am roaming between two active receiveable systems or just locked on one; the current bleedthru mostly appears to come from TG's I am actively scanning and not usually from those I have not selected unlike back in the early days of owning the device; current sw/fw is 2021-02-23 1415 as of today, Wednesday, February 24th, 2021 at about 12:59 PM local.

So, hopefully, this observation will help you solve this issue!

But I have a feature request that I have always wanted but now, given the above observations,it has become more prominate: 1) Show in the Talk Group Log screen whether the traffic is P1 or P2; and 2) Show in both the Console screen and the Talk Group Log (if #1 is implimented, of course) which slot is being used during TDMA P2 traffic reception.

I really like that you have added RID logging, BTW! I knew this would be a heavily requested feature going forward. One thing that I think would be nice, if I may sneak in another "feature request" , is that I think it would aid the logging and analysis of RID's in using them to work out what unknown TG's are being used for if you added a column for listing the associated TG's for a given RID in the RID "Alias" tab. It might get too cluttered in busy systems but could be a user selectable feature.

All for now, hope the above info helps! Still love the device and am glad to see it gaining ground with more users and maturing in capability!

-Mike
 

btt

Jew lover
Banned
Joined
Mar 11, 2020
Messages
2,585
Location
Wa State
@Mike_G_D,

Thank you for the detailed post and suggestions. I thought this issue was solved with all the recent changes to the P2 code! I'm going to look this over closely and dig through the code and see what I can find. Since you are monitoring multiple systems, I wonder if there are shared talk group ids for both systems that are getting through because the SYS_ID and WACN are not up-to-date when the TG with an identical value for a different system comes through? As soon as I get back to working on the scanning mode, I will be adding columns for defining the SYS_ID, WACN for the control channels (vs waiting for them to be received). The latest versions should be keeping this information persistent across frequency changes, but there could be some bugs. I will get some more information added to the logs and the column for the TG in the alias tab as suggested sometime next week. Thanks!
 

Cheeseburgers

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 9, 2018
Messages
637
I have it on my desk at work paired with a Shure 700mhz antenna and its going like a champ, out performed my G4 and my 325p2. Todd has a winner here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: btt
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top