I am beginning to think that your 660 may be working as it should. Today at midday - the worst possible time - I went hunting for some weak stations and here's what I found.
The signal strengths were measured on my HP 3586A selective level meter from a 45metre/15metre ocfd through a 9:1 balun directly to the SLM. The Tecsun 600 and the GE Superadio ll were just on their internal ferrite antennas.
Frequency 567 kHz, RNZ National programme, Titahi Bay 118km away, -118dBm, say 0.5uV EMF, the 600 gave a noisy but readable signal but no "S" meter indication, my GE gave a good signal with very slight background noise. Powerful transmitter.
Frequency 594kHz, Star Radio, Wanganui, 71km away, -112dBm, 1.2uV EMF, 600 gave good signal clean audio and 2 "S" meter points, the GE radio was clean audio with no noise.
Frequency 1071kHz, Masterton, 75km, -119dBm, 0.3uV EMF, on the 600 barely audible and no "S" meter reading, the GE radio was about the same - over the Tararua Ranges so not unexpected.
Frequency 1602kHz, the Radio Reading Service in Levin, 54km, -112dBm, on the 600 noisy and unreadable, on the GE noisy but readable. Very local low power transmitter.
The weather was overcast with drizzle and low cloud.
It's 60km or so from Wanaka to Alexandra and I recall that the transmitter is up on the flat by the airport so your results would seem to be about par for the course. Still there's some hills in the way.