Is the channel digital or analog?
If digital, do both scanners have the same "wait times" and no others things going on like one is recording but the other is not?
If digital do both scanner have "digital only" selected or is one set for "Auto" for type of modulation?
What ever the channel is; try the same experiment with the other type of modulation, i.e. if it is analog try doing the same thing with a digital channel and see if you get the same results.
This sort of thing is something I usually do with my scanner (comparing one to another and different antennas) but I just got my 436 yesterday and am still in learning mode.
Looks like Jay911 beat me to it while I was still typing.
I will have to check all the settings tomorrow. I am not short about wait times etc. Probably the default settings because I haven't learned how to manipulate that stuff yet
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk