Trained in health and safety, including being responsible for tax payers monies, (etc) it just drives me nuts. Not too also to mention, the lack of insight by others on this specific issue.
Ditto concerning cell phones; including the costs of encryption and false sense of security.
I also too speculate, people are trying to get AST out of the civilian policing. Most States restrict State policing to the highways, while utilizing more localized policing for civilians to provide that touchy feel-ly feeling when needed. ;-)
You are so correct, Police or those in power, earn more respect when using lesser force to defuse a situation rather than just shooting up the neighborhood. Granted, there's more stress involved. (ie. The Andy Griffith Show ;-)
However, within Fairbanks/North Pole, nobody wants an FNSB Sheriff. And from viewing how the FNSB wants to outlaw wood stoves for residents living within -60F temps, they seem too irrational to be able to wield such power. But, as I further think, this could be due to the distance AST keeps itself from the populace, leaving the FNSB without proper advice as it doesn't have a Sheriff's department to forewarn them of their imperfections. (ie. When I worked, people would mention it's probably not wise to do something, and then further explain if it wasn't understood.)
I'm not too worried, about the State becoming a dictatorship, even though this is basically what would transpire just prior, I'm more worried about people playing games without the fear of being held liable for the damage that they do. I, myself, realize I cannot play games unless the stakes are high enough. Even then, if I do play games, I also realize I will likely loose everything I have gained because I played games. Basic fear of God principle, as such, honesty is a best policy.
You can't put a price on an injury or loss of life, even though the Courts try. A few posts here, might well be worth the risk. ;-)
I'm retired now and stating my brief observations. I assume everybody else have a job, and signed to a non-disclosure agreement.