SDS100/SDS200: I'm trying to convince my manager to buy 2 SDS200 scanners.

RJBTVTech

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2024
Messages
16
Reaction score
7
Location
Troy, NY
Hi, it's been a year since I've posted. I'm a staff engineer at an upstate NY television station. I'm trying to convince my management to purchase 2 new SDS200 scanners because we need the ability to hear Project 25 Phase II with Simulcast. We want to split the police to one scanner, and fire and EMS to the other one. I have some questions, but first, here's the Uniden scanners that we're currently using:
  • BCD996XT (for Law Enforcement)
  • BCD996T (for Fire/EMS)
  • BC895XLT (for what I don't know, I don't think the frequencies it's looking at are even active)
  • BC-760XLT (I think it's looking at legacy frequencies).
Now for the questions:
  1. Is this still the best scanner for Project 25 Phase II with Simulcast, right?
  2. Do we need any more accessories than what comes with the units?
  3. We have an antenna on the roof of our building, and I can reuse the powered speakers that are on the BCD996XT and the BCD996T. Is there anything I'm forgetting?
Thank you for any advice you can give me!
 

paulears

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2015
Messages
929
Reaction score
402
Location
Lowestoft - UK
As a Brit, I do find it amusing the IT manager won’t allow software to be installed because it could let unapproved outsiders get access to their network, when the software you want allows your company to have unwanted access to other peoples systems? The irony! News organisations here have had no access to emergency services for 25 years, and just make the stories up from social media posts.
 

chrismol1

Active Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2008
Messages
1,411
Reaction score
1,332
As a Brit, I do find it amusing the IT manager won’t allow software to be installed because it could let unapproved outsiders get access to their network, when the software you want allows your company to have unwanted access to other peoples systems? The irony! News organisations here have had no access to emergency services for 25 years, and just make the stories up from social media posts.
As an American, I find your posts interesting. If I shout across the pond and other people hear me, I should be upset about that while although there is a precedent for encryption to relieve that issue has been for decades in the UK. I also find it amusing you have such ideas of privacy, yet your country is over the brim filled with public safety cameras, speed cameras, AI cameras now detecting seat belt, mobile phone violations and other driving violations as well as beyond ensuring proper registration and taxes. The differences between visible light and non-visible light waves. I suppose that is our differences and has been for some centuries.
 

paulears

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2015
Messages
929
Reaction score
402
Location
Lowestoft - UK
100% agree - we're so close to the US on so much, but miles apart on others. Ring doorbells here break our GDPR regulations, yet if there is a burglary, the Police ask anyone with them to review the footage and let them have it. Legally we can buy scanners and baofeng (and zillions of others) and yet we still have a bit of legislation that says you can't listen. I'm very involved with marine radio, and oddly have a licence for testing and demonstrating them on land? Yet they made me take the test to use them on boats, which I never do? Our police have a country wide system that can, if necessary, be permissioned to connect fire and ambulance who use the same network, but finding a senior officer and then tec support to enable it means they don't. even sillier - their radios have the usual digital features, yet many officers carry two separate identical radios, rather than have one monitoring both nets? I wanted to hire some airband radios to an airfield for an event where one main tower frequency wasn't enough. They wanted to charge me thousands for a frequency for one day, and nothing would shift them. for data protection reasons, many county police forces also insist officers wear earpieces - no public hearing of their radios! We have rules on child protection and privacy, yet most schools use public band radios that dodgy folk could use to their advantage - they use our PMR446 system in most cases, yet they could easily toughen it up with digital. vehicle licence plate cameras are everywhere and they also use these to enforce speeding - as in they read your plate leaving my town at 8.10, but you got to the next time quicker than the speed/distance allows. every car park monitor vehicle's plates now. even small towns have security cameras everywhere - usually run by local councils, but the authorities have access. However - we do NOT have freedom of speech. It's effectively gone despite what our Prime Minister claims. He says we do, yet we have a guy who drives a large panel van to political events all over the country. On the side is a big photo of the prime minister - and it says Kier Starmer is a w*nker. He gets his van seized every single time for 'causing offence'. offence to the man who says we have free speech. Us Brits are a joke. People are proudly flying our union flag, the scottish flag and the welsh flags - everywhere! The authorities are taking them down as quick, because it causes offence to immigrants. It is like a soap opera - apologies for derailing the topic.
 

wa8pyr

Retired and playing radio whenever I want.
Staff member
Lead Database Admin
Joined
Sep 22, 2002
Messages
7,642
Reaction score
4,182
Location
Ohio
Knowing and loving our local TV assignment desk folks as I do, I'd think they would prefer to have physical scanners than SDR dongles.

The SDR dongles are spectacular for seasoned folks, but news desk folks might want to keep things as simple as possible.
Concur. I did quite a bit of consulting work for a couple of our area tv stations several years ago. The name of the game is ‘keep it simple‘ when it comes to the assignment desk; last thing they need in the middle of a breaking news situation is for the SDR setup to crap out, and all of a sudden they’re hearing nothing.

Plus, there’s probably not enough room on the assignment desk for the computers/monitors to run multiple SDR setups.
 

RJBTVTech

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2024
Messages
16
Reaction score
7
Location
Troy, NY
Concur. I did quite a bit of consulting work for a couple of our area tv stations several years ago. The name of the game is ‘keep it simple‘ when it comes to the assignment desk; last thing they need in the middle of a breaking news situation is for the SDR setup to crap out, and all of a sudden they’re hearing nothing.

Plus, there’s probably not enough room on the assignment desk for the computers/monitors to run multiple SDR setups.
There are already 2 computers, with 2 monitors each on a "L" shaped counter/desk, in an 8' x 6' assignment desk area. The space for the scanners is a 1' deep, 2' wide platform with 2 scanners on top and 2 underneath.
 

dmfalk

Active Member
Joined
May 16, 2024
Messages
606
Reaction score
497
Location
Eureka
Just to reiterate, keep in mind that Sentinel is OEM software, made by Uniden, and only works with 4 models (436HP, 536HP, SDS100, SDS200), and is definitely NOT open source. Even though it's free to download, it's useless outside of being used with specific scanners. IT should approve OEM software, out if necessity.
 

RJBTVTech

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2024
Messages
16
Reaction score
7
Location
Troy, NY
Just to reiterate, keep in mind that Sentinel is OEM software, made by Uniden, and only works with 4 models (436HP, 536HP, SDS100, SDS200), and is definitely NOT open source. Even though it's free to download, it's useless outside of being used with specific scanners. IT should approve OEM software, out if necessity.
Since it's needed for the scanners they'll know about it and approve it. It's probably going to be installed on the laptop that isn't on the corporate domain network anyway.
 

dmfalk

Active Member
Joined
May 16, 2024
Messages
606
Reaction score
497
Location
Eureka
Sentinel is required for keeping the scanner firmware up to date. Please check your PM.
Especially as they don't come updated, nor having the DMR and NXDN options activated. And you will need to update both firmware and master database. (Last firmware update was earlier this year, and the database update is weekly, on Mondays.)
 

Redneck0410

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Mar 3, 2008
Messages
1,015
Reaction score
17
Location
Hutchinson, KS
Especially as they don't come updated, nor having the DMR and NXDN options activated. And you will need to update both firmware and master database. (Last firmware update was earlier this year, and the database update is weekly, on Mondays.)
New firmware just rolled out earlier this week.
 

tvengr

Well Known Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
11,523
Reaction score
4,912
Location
Baltimore County, MD
Hi, it's been a year since I've posted. I'm a staff engineer at an upstate NY television station. I'm trying to convince my management to purchase 2 new SDS200 scanners because we need the ability to hear Project 25 Phase II with Simulcast. We want to split the police to one scanner, and fire and EMS to the other one.
Please check your PM. There are 2 favorites lists for you.
 
Top