gman1971
Member
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2020
- Messages
- 159
By some... you mean, Most? As in, most of those CCR radios are inferior to even radios that were made in the 80s... ? I've tested nearly every CCR made to date, with an ISOTEE, these things are just pretty polished turds.
25 years ago there wasn't the explosion of RF noise that we've had in the last decade, wifi, cell towers, etc...
Its not the receiver design or sensitivity what really matters, really. Most receivers today can hear down to -130 dBm easily... plenty of sensitivity, its the ability to reject all the unwanted noise/signals around the desired frequencies what matters the most, especially now. That is where most of these CCRs fall way sort. Most of those CCRs, when connected directly to the Service Monitor, they perform just as good as the best XPR7550e... once you take them out and run the ISOTEE test, you have a massive 30 dB desense, those 'things' are garbage.
Hytera is one of the better CCRs no doubt, but it just so happens they stole Motorola engineering designs, processes, etc... so of course they are better. I suspect there is also IP theft/sharing between Anytone and Hytera too... b/c there are uncanny similarities between their radio interfaces... who knows.
G.
25 years ago there wasn't the explosion of RF noise that we've had in the last decade, wifi, cell towers, etc...
Its not the receiver design or sensitivity what really matters, really. Most receivers today can hear down to -130 dBm easily... plenty of sensitivity, its the ability to reject all the unwanted noise/signals around the desired frequencies what matters the most, especially now. That is where most of these CCRs fall way sort. Most of those CCRs, when connected directly to the Service Monitor, they perform just as good as the best XPR7550e... once you take them out and run the ISOTEE test, you have a massive 30 dB desense, those 'things' are garbage.
Hytera is one of the better CCRs no doubt, but it just so happens they stole Motorola engineering designs, processes, etc... so of course they are better. I suspect there is also IP theft/sharing between Anytone and Hytera too... b/c there are uncanny similarities between their radio interfaces... who knows.
G.
There's no mystery to 900Mhz FHSS, and you don't need an expensive sophisticated superhet design - direct sampling is most often employed. I used to write firmware for 900Mhz RFID interrogators - the high speed tollway type. If I can pickup backscatter at 100mph, you can bet that it's gonna be a lot easier job for something purpose designed for communications. This was 25 years ago.
Although some Chinese radios are indeed cheaply (or rather, poorly) built, not all and not even most. The fact is, technology, especially *digital* technology amortizes itself *way* faster than way you'd think - and *that's* why we have so many inexpensive radios. Of course, all the big LMR players have their radios built where labor is cheap - and there's not all that much new under the analog sun, and there's little incentive for Chinese companies to *not* copy designs. Who can blame them? You exploit their cheap labor to sell at usurious prices in the west, they copy your designs... There's no such thing as a free lunch.
Last edited: