2
Will this scanner get me covered for the P25 Phase II?
Whistler WS1065 Digital Desktop/Mobile Radio Scanner?
I have some other ideas for my WS 1040, upload and listen to what I can listen to.
My PSR-600's that I use as a base and in one car, are fine for everything in my somewhat remote two county area. There is only one P25 Phase 2 system in operation and is the second trunked system in the county, is for Southern California Edison (SCE). It isn't simulcast up here, but is in other parts of the system in southern California. I don't need the SDS models so I didn't buy one. I don't care for the busy screens on each either. So I bought a Phase 2 scanner, the Uniden BCD325P2. I need something for SCE that will work with AA batteries as I always have plenty charged up and have a solar unit just for charging small batteries. I have a PSR-500 and a PRO-96 for all conventional and trunking minus the Phase 2. We will be visiting family in Scottsdale this Christmas and they live in a place where I could not pick up the older P25 Phase 1 repeaters, except Thompson Peak, which I can see from my wife's brother and SIL's house. I will be excited to see how this non simulcast radio will do under the circumstances. I know if I get some simulcast distortion I can always attenuate the signal and that might solve the problem.
My point is, that if your home is in a location, as KB7MIB mentioned, where you can only pick up one repeater, a non-simulcast scanner may do the trick. But, when you are mobile it will not work well.
Another disadvantage with the SDS-100 is the use of a proprietary (brand & model specific manufacturing) battery. I don't want this as in an emergency I can only use that battery, along with specific chargers, for the radio. The last proprietary battery I purchased was for a BC-100 back in the later 1980's. If Uniden doesn't come up with a AA battery scanner, I will have to live without a simulcast scanner until they do. My wife and I have a friend and ex RR member who lives in Payson, Arizona, who along with her late husband, did far more backpacking and boondocking than my career allowed for. She still has the solar chargers they rolled out onto their backpacks and at boondocking camps to keep AA's charged up for their scanners and ham radios. She is even more strongly opposed to proprietary batteries than I am. She wrote this in one thread and everyone tried to convince her she was wrong. She didn't budge and bought the 325P2 before I did. We both noted that Uniden screwed up in a few places, but the biggest problem is the 2 AA's get eaten up in 4 hours, sometimes less, sometimes more, depending on the amount of traffic received. It does plug into a computer for charging and linking to software so it works nicely on a desk. Without power though, the GRE's are far better. If GRE or Whistler was making a handheld Phase 2, simulcast scanner, they would likely go with AA batteries. GRE is gone for good. I don't think Whistler will ever make new scanner model, they have more profitable products.