Avidhiker, if you read some of the above posts, there were others who also had terrible experiences with the Bcd436. I am not the only one. And Yes, Union Twp. appears to be going encrypted on NJICS. Roselle Pk is already encrypted, Roselle, Linden, and Elizabeth also encrypt several PD transmisions. Plainfield and Rahway are encrypted (Rahway for years now). I would be shocked if Cranford and Kenilworth actually stay in the clear once they switch over to NJICS. So, much of Union County is encrypted and I PROMISE you that we will see several more departments encrypted by 2019 according to my inside sources. Good luck with that soon to be paperweight scanner.
Everybody's listening situation is completely different. Variables can change reception completely in the span of inches. I personally love my 436 and have zero problems decoding NJICS, Somerset County and other P25 I/II & DMR systems. Newark FD sounds fine as do most other transmissions i hear on both the Union County Simulcast and the West Orange simulcast. I get some modulation and bad decodes every once in a while but i'd say i get 99% of the transmissions 100% of the time. I wouldn't say a scanner is bad just because of one persons experience everyone has a different situation that can have different results.
I see the encryption rumor mill still going and going and going and is not even part of the discussion here but of course "your inside sources" must know otherwise. Until someone can confirm 100% encrypted transmissions on a particular frequency or system how about you hold off on the speculation. Its stupid speculation that gets everybody all worked up and keeps the rumor mill going.