But it does have to do with how you you distribute the list (spelled) of how to speak it. And in fact, U.S. military EAM messages are not only spoken, they are distributed as spelled out as phonetics in the NATO spellings so that they are read as such. An actual one from a USN TACAMO aircraft transmitting on VLF (17.8 kHz, 50 Bd/50 Hz shift):"Phonetic Alphabet" refers to how they are "Spoken" has nothing to do with how they are Spelled!
Would that not be "Phonetic Alphabet " to "Alfa Numeric" conversionBut it does have to do with how you you distribute the list (spelled) of how to speak it. And in fact, U.S. military EAM messages are not only spoken, they are distributed as spelled out as phonetics in the NATO spellings so that they are read as such. An actual one from a USN TACAMO aircraft transmitting on VLF (17.8 kHz, 50 Bd/50 Hz shift):
NNNNKKKKKKZCZCZCZXLLXLLXLL
ZZ
BT
MIKE VICTOR LIMA DELTA
JULIETT ZULU PAPA YANKEE
ROMEO YANKEE ALFA OSCAR
DELTA FOXTROT QUEBEC
INDIA SIERRA YANKEE
QUEBEC CHARLIE ROMEO
VICTOR FOUR FOUR DELTA
ROMEO KILO FIVE
BT
NNN
Adam, Boy, Charles, David, Edward, Frank, George...
The problem is that foreign speakers do not pronounce the single "t" and double "tt" the some.How does one discern if Julie[tt] was spoken with one 't' or two 't's?
The ITU phonetic alphabet is just that - Phonetic. If I want the write down an "A" I'll write A, not Alfa or Alpha. If I want to speak an "A" I'll say "Alfa". It's a pity that some operators have fancy phonetics that they have dreamed up as they think they sound cool - I beg to differ. If I want to reply someone who uses his/her fancy phonetics, I'll use the ITU phonetics - maybe he/she will learn something.
The double "t" would have a slight "teh" sound at the end: "Joo-lee-et-teh" 😁How does one discern if Julie[tt] was spoken with one 't' or two 't's?
Wouldn't EAM's be so much more interesting if they used the "funky" phonetic alphabet?In some critical cases (like miltary EAM messages), forcing to write the whole alphanumeric acts as a form of error correction. And a single letter could be misread as opposed to misreading a spelled out alphanumeric. (Just like spelling certain important words as some message traffic nets require instead of just saying it. Like you, I do not like fancy phonetics but excuse them if they help remember a callsign (which I likely will not anyway).