Your friendly moderator suggests that if you intend to start down the "reinvent amateur radio" path, that you start a new thread focused on that topic.
Maybe start with examining the the FCC's definition of the basis and purpose of amateur radio. Does that need to change?
But, don't lose sight of the fact that amateur radio is world wide. The IARU has some resources that might give direction to the conversation from an international perspective. Starting with the IARU definition of amateur radio:
What is Amateur Radio? | International Amateur Radio Union (IARU)