Post-Helene Comms

wx9svr

Active Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Nov 4, 2004
Messages
543
Reaction score
647

chtucker

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Sep 5, 2020
Messages
5
Reaction score
5
Just because I am a nerd-



September 28, 2 days after the hurricane Helene hit North Carolina- almost 75% of the cellular sites were off the air due to backhaul or power issues. Only 7 out of 1450 were off the air due to damage.



October 11, 16 days later all of the damaged sites are repaired (which implies minor damage), and about 100 sites are still off the air due to backhaul or power issues.



Hurricane Helene

Hurricane Milton





If you look at 2 days for Milton in Florida, less than 2 days in for that storm—

More than 10% of sites are off the air in the affected area, ONLY .13% are due to damage. 9% are due to power and 3% are due to backhaul.



Pretty easy to see where the cellular weak spots are- and what can be done better. Power. Power. Backhaul.
 

jeepsandradios

Member
Feed Provider
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
2,523
Reaction score
1,865
Location
East of the Mississippi
Sadly cellular is no where near what it was when it first went in. Most sites have very limited battery backup and if they have a generator on site its a small unit with not a ton of fuel. 20 years ago I'd walk into a verizon shelter and half the site was battereis. Now its a pedistal on a pad. Before the storm cell was not the greatest as it is in some of those areas. Its also a big differnce in restoration when you pull off the main paved road and drive 15' to the tower compound vs 2 miles up a poorly maintained mountain road.

But I get your point.
 

chtucker

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Sep 5, 2020
Messages
5
Reaction score
5
Sadly cellular is no where near what it was when it first went in. Most sites have very limited battery backup and if they have a generator on site its a small unit with not a ton of fuel. 20 years ago I'd walk into a verizon shelter and half the site was battereis. Now its a pedistal on a pad. Before the storm cell was not the greatest as it is in some of those areas. Its also a big differnce in restoration when you pull off the main paved road and drive 15' to the tower compound vs 2 miles up a poorly maintained mountain road.

But I get your point.
But FirstNet, Verizon’s & T Mobile first responder programs are sold as reliable and mission critical communications…

I wish there were some more detailed data with carrier specific information.

I believe all the carriers should be required to have 72-120 hours of backup power… not reliant on someone towing a generator somewhere.
 

spacellamaman

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2014
Messages
1,529
Reaction score
877
Location
municipality of great state of insanity
KZTL NOTAM

10/749 - AIRSPACE DISASTER AND RECOVERY OPS WI AN AREA DEFINED AS .5NM RADIUS OF 353542N0822408W
(SUG336013) TEMPO HEL LDG ZONE ADVISORY SVC 122.925 DLY 1132-2344. 23 OCT 11:32
2024 UNTIL 22 NOV 23:44 2024. CREATED: 22 OCT 19:32 2024
 
Top