CMPD on Mobile Scanner

Status
Not open for further replies.

nloder

Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2004
Messages
5
Location
Charlotte, NC
I have been using a Uniden BCD436HP to monitor CMPD and Charlotte-Mecklenburg MEDIC, and the simulcast distortion is terrible! I live in south Charlotte, but the problem is persistent throughout the county.

Is there a better scanner model, perhaps with updated software, for monitoring P25 with simulcast distortion? I have tried different attenuation settings to no avail. I am considering installing an antenna and mobile scanner in my vehicle.. would that help? It seems like the handheld 436HP is sensitive to the way it is held- for example if I pick up the scanner during a transmission, it will drop out as soon as I touch it.

Any tried and true vehicle antenna and unit combinations for monitoring the Charlotte-Meck P25 system would be appreciated!
 

JRush311

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 17, 2017
Messages
126
Location
Monroe, N.C.
Ive been through this already , I live in charlotte also
you wont be able to hear crap
and an antenna will not help

your only real solution is a motorola radio which is difficult
or a Unication G4 or G5 pager
the unication decodes LSM perfectly
 

28056

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Messages
82
Location
Mesquite TX
Ive been through this already , I live in charlotte also
you wont be able to hear crap
and an antenna will not help

your only real solution is a motorola radio which is difficult
or a Unication G4 or G5 pager
the unication decodes LSM perfectly


You forgot about the Relm KNG.


Not cheap, but if you need P25 phase II NOW, the only option.
 

RF-Burns

Member
Joined
May 5, 2007
Messages
281
Sell the scanners and buy yourself a Unication G4/G5. Hands down it is a great preforming radio. I have mine programmed on the Charlotte UASI System and the NC Viper System. Absolutely zero multi-site distortion. Scanner manufactures have a lot of work to do because the vision of Unication doesn't stop at pagers for the future.

The other option is to buy a Harris P7100/P7200/P7300 with Option 39 (P25 Trunking) they work fantastic. Harris radios give you more control over a Unication Pager. For example on a Unication Pager you set the scan list in the programming software and you can't change it. Harris Radios you can control the scan list, turn scan on and off and so on right from the radio.

Another option is you can buy a Motorola radio. We can't talk about that on here but yes it can be done and yes they work very well. A little less control than a Harris Radio but yes it can be done.

EF Johnson 5100's are good and use all the same accessories as Motorola XTS3000s and XTS5000s so accessories are cheap. I've personally never used a 5100 for trunking but I do know people who do and they all work very well.

Lastly, if you can find a BK Radio they work very well. Very expensive and hard to find though.

All these options provide ZERO multi-site distortion. I have given up on scanners and have sold all of mine. Until Upman and Uniden step up to the plate and build what is really needed in this hobby then they will continue to fail.

(I blurred out my name on the Unication pic)
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:

28056

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Messages
82
Location
Mesquite TX
isnt charlotte phase 1?

Probably.... For now. I was posting in general in case there were a phase II system that someone wants to monitor.

Be glad you can still monitor, out here the trend is moving towards heavy encryption. My city just switched over and so far all police and fire comms are 100% encrypted along with another city on the system.
 

nloder

Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2004
Messages
5
Location
Charlotte, NC
Well I’m excited that there’s an option to at least allow clear reception of the Charlotte UASI. I just purchased a Unication G4 from Ray’s Pagers, and look forward to programming it! If anyone can share a program file for the Charlotte UASI system, that would be awesome...otherwise I assume there is enough info on Radioreference to program it myself.

Thanks again everyone, for the responses.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

G4guy5891

Newbie
Joined
Nov 9, 2017
Messages
3
I live in the same area and can confirm the G4 is fantastic for CMPD, CFD and Medic. You will not be disappointed with the pager. The only issue recently has been trying to connect to a Bluetooth speaker or wireless headphones. After many failed attempts I decided to purchase the amplified charger base as that has received some good reviews. Programming is pretty simple as well.
 

RF-Burns

Member
Joined
May 5, 2007
Messages
281
Glad to hear you bought a G4. They are very easy to program, if you have any issues them please reach out.

Just a side note on the G4. I would suggest programming each site (county) as its own system. The UASI system does not use Omni-Link so if you are in Mecklenburg County and you want to listen to a call in Cabarrus County you couldn't because your G4 will be receiving the Mecklenburg County Site. Programming each county as its own system you can listen to Cabarrus County if you wanted to from Mecklenburg or another county that's within ranch of the G4. You will need to put in the System ID, RFSS (1) and Site ID for each Site.

Hope this info helps, enjoy your new pager.

Motoman55

Well I’m excited that there’s an option to at least allow clear reception of the Charlotte UASI. I just purchased a Unication G4 from Ray’s Pagers, and look forward to programming it! If anyone can share a program file for the Charlotte UASI system, that would be awesome...otherwise I assume there is enough info on Radioreference to program it myself.

Thanks again everyone, for the responses.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Soundman

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2001
Messages
407
Location
N.C
What antenna are you using on your BCD436HP ? I am using the radio shack 800 band antenna and mine work pretty good .I would love to get a g4 but don't have the cash.
 

nwalshjr

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
44
Location
Huntersville NC
I have been using a Uniden BCD436HP to monitor CMPD and Charlotte-Mecklenburg MEDIC, and the simulcast distortion is terrible! I live in south Charlotte, but the problem is persistent throughout the county.



Is there a better scanner model, perhaps with updated software, for monitoring P25 with simulcast distortion? I have tried different attenuation settings to no avail. I am considering installing an antenna and mobile scanner in my vehicle.. would that help? It seems like the handheld 436HP is sensitive to the way it is held- for example if I pick up the scanner during a transmission, it will drop out as soon as I touch it.



Any tried and true vehicle antenna and unit combinations for monitoring the Charlotte-Meck P25 system would be appreciated!


I gave up on Uniden. I am now monitoring the USAI system with a Unication G5. It works almost flawlessly. There are no issues with the simulcast distortion.

It is designed more like a real radio. It has a normal volume button and a channel selector (eight positions). It also handles “priority” scanning with no problem. It beeps when you are out of range of a tower. I drove north on I-77 and was just getting to Statesville before being out of range.

I live in Huntersville. I can monitor anything in Mecklenburg, Cabarrus, and Mooresville with no problem. I have not tried to program other areas at this point.
 

PJH

Database Admin
Database Admin
Joined
Aug 23, 2002
Messages
3,568
The workaround for P25 simulcast systems (until the scanner community can make improvements) is to use a Yagi antenna at your closest site.

That seems to work very well on those system.

The Unications are great, but very pricey for single system listening.

P2 release will be awesome. I've seen demo's of it and its extremely well engineered. They are just working on some backend things to maintain the integrity of the product.

There is a major update to the USAI system that took place, with proper GPS ranges and locations set. It should be fully implemented in the next Uniden pull.

Counties outside of Charlotte were not ranged and potentially not loaded into the x36 or other location aware equipment.
 

KD4UXQ

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2004
Messages
223
The workaround for P25 simulcast systems (until the scanner community can make improvements) is to use a Yagi antenna at your closest site.

That seems to work very well on those system.

The Unications are great, but very pricey for single system listening.

P2 release will be awesome. I've seen demo's of it and its extremely well engineered. They are just working on some backend things to maintain the integrity of the product.

There is a major update to the USAI system that took place, with proper GPS ranges and locations set. It should be fully implemented in the next Uniden pull.

Counties outside of Charlotte were not ranged and potentially not loaded into the x36 or other location aware equipment.
I have setup a Yagi indoors to solve the simulcast issue in Rowan County. I receive one site full scale and transmissions are clear with 0 BER, or very close to it all the time. There are some really cheap 760 MHz ones on eBay right now, but supply is getting low The one I bought is 12dBi gain and I had to put a 6dB attenuator inline to reduce reception of the other sites. It receives 800MHz just fine as expected. The only drawback of course is not portable.
 

nitroboie

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2006
Messages
289
Location
Charlotte, NC
I've had decent luck with manually using a threshold of 7 on my 436. It's not VIPER clear but it holds an error rate in the teens at the most. Radio Shack 800mhz antenna. University Area.
 

Baddad

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 30, 2005
Messages
36
Location
Hickory & Clt, NC
G5

I'm inside the 277 loop and get Central Division's main channel ok, but nothing else from CMPD. Which version of the G5 would ya'll recommend for stuff outside of UASI?
 

RF-Burns

Member
Joined
May 5, 2007
Messages
281
I'm inside the 277 loop and get Central Division's main channel ok, but nothing else from CMPD. Which version of the G5 would ya'll recommend for stuff outside of UASI?
If you want to just listen to just trunked systems then the G4 is what I would recommend. If you want to hear anything on VHF or UHF then the G5 is what you would need. The trunking on both the G4 & G5 is the exact same the only difference on the G5 is the introduction of VHF/UHF
 

kg4pbd

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
802
I'm inside the 277 loop and get Central Division's main channel ok, but nothing else from CMPD. Which version of the G5 would ya'll recommend for stuff outside of UASI?
Which system are you monitoring? By any chance is it the old system 0F18? Central is the only CMPD division still carried on that system. If Central is all you are hearing you may be listening to the old system.

If you are monitoring the P25 UASI system, and you can hear Central, then you can hear all the divisions.

A G4 or G5 is what you would want for monitoring the P25 UASI system, as that is where you have the LSM distortion issues.
 

Baddad

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Dec 30, 2005
Messages
36
Location
Hickory & Clt, NC
I guess I misspoke. I'm listening to Central on the old Motorola system. I've let the P25 UASI run for hours at a time on my 396XT, but don't hear anything. LS distortion for sure. Therefore I'm looking at the G5 for the USAI system.

Other Other than UASI, I listen to the buildings & businesses around me, that aren't DMR, so I'm considering the 400-470 Mhz model.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top