In re: Delete, Delete, Delete FCC looks to eliminate rules and regulations

K5MPH

Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
1,669
Location
Brownsville Texas,On The Border By The Sea.
Yeah, I disagree.
While it would be nice for -SOME- to have their ham license, or GMRS, or GROL, or whatever, it's not necessary or required.
Having all 3 myself, I don't see much value in it for someone at the FCC to be able to do their job.

The police officer/speeding ticket strawman doesn't hold up, since it would ultimately come down to a judge to interpret the law. Someone simply having a drivers license, or amateur radio license for that matter, doesn't impress me. Having a ham radio license is the floor, not the ceiling. Passing grade on a 35 question multiple choice test doesn't make one an expert.
I agree with you so passing a test to be an Extra class where all you have to do is memorize the answers to the questions don't prove a thing and sure don't make you smarter.......
 

kc2asb

Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2015
Messages
620
Location
NYC Area
I agree with you so passing a test to be an Extra class where all you have to do is memorize the answers to the questions don't prove a thing and sure don't make you smarter.......
Doubt we will ever see the amateur license testing switched to an essay format. That would certainly starve the hobby of new entrants. :)
 

K9KLC

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 31, 2007
Messages
1,043
Location
Southwest, IL
Doubt we will ever see the amateur license testing switched to an essay format. That would certainly starve the hobby of new entrants. :)
My father always tried to ingrain in me "quality over quantity". While that's not always popular, my answer for ham radio too.
 

kc2asb

Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2015
Messages
620
Location
NYC Area
My father always tried to ingrain in me "quality over quantity". While that's not always popular, my answer for ham radio too.

A very important concept that I wish I had an appreciation for a little earlier in life. With the threat of losing spectrum, ham radio may not have that luxury. Plus the VE's would not want the burden of grading essays. :)
 

K9KLC

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 31, 2007
Messages
1,043
Location
Southwest, IL
A very important concept that I wish I had an appreciation for a little earlier in life. With the threat of losing spectrum, ham radio may not have that luxury. Plus the VE's would not want the burden of grading essays. :)
No, I'm sure the VE's wouldn't regarding the essay thing. That being said, how many of the current crop that get licensed, get a CCR, only the rubber duck antenna, start complaining they can't talk to anyone and just stop, are gonna help fight for spectrum?

If they get the CCR, then carry on in other areas great. I'm all for that but many don't. My only hope is some of the young people recently licensed the club maintain the enthusiasm they currently have and move forward at the rate they are currently at.

I hope other areas and clubs have the same success we've had. It's great to watch Jr. High kids get involved and move forward.
 

w4amp

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
426
Location
Dallas, Georgia
Wondering, out loud, if anyone submitted a request to force all amateurs to get their Morse Code test done. After all, "no-code" brought about the "End of the hobby!!!!!!!".
LOL

In all fairness, I would rather work a Tech that is enjoying the hobby than a 1x2 or 2x1 no code extra that thinks they know everything.

My 29 year old parrot CC does not like the no coders. As can be seen in his pic, he has a mean foot on the paddles. He only does 5 wpm, but he has DXCC on ten cw.

CC has been mad lately at the refrigerator. While ordering the groceries my refrigerator has 200 confirmed on 20 digital with FT8.

:)
 

K9KLC

Member
Premium Subscriber
Joined
Mar 31, 2007
Messages
1,043
Location
Southwest, IL
LOL

In all fairness, I would rather work a Tech that is enjoying the hobby than a 1x2 or 2x1 no code extra that thinks they know everything.

My 29 year old parrot CC does not like the no coders. As can be seen in his pic, he has a mean foot on the paddles. He only does 5 wpm, but he has DXCC on ten cw.

CC has been mad lately at the refrigerator. While ordering the groceries my refrigerator has 200 confirmed on 20 digital with FT8.

:)
It's never been about the class of the license, rather the class of the operator. I've been a general since 1996 and I am aware of what I know, don't know, and what I've done in the hobby. Those that know me personally also know. We're proud of the licenses we have currently from tech-extra. I guess one day I might sit for the extra but, truthfully that's only to help the club for testing.
 

AK9R

Lead Wiki Manager and almost an Awesome Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
10,315
Location
Central Indiana
The ARRL filed comments on amateur radio topics in response to this FCC request for input: ARRL Files Comments on FCC

Full text of ARRL comments here: ECFS

There have been over 900 comments filed in response to the FCC request: ECFS
 
Last edited:
Top