I spent 2007 to 2009 in Iraq, yes...I do know what the hell Im talking about. I did travel from base to base (wasnt a fobit)...small arms, mortars, etc...thats normal to encounter quite often when in an artillery unit..yes, we've searched buildings, and yes, we did have to deal with IEDs...so dont make the mistake of thinking Im some fat ass on a sofa talking about stuff I have no clue about.
Blizzard, first and most important (at least to me), thank you for your service. I have the utmost respect for you and what our military has to do to protect all of us.
My knowledge of your job is probably a little better than the average civilian, due to my background and the fact I am an amateur military historian, but I am still a civilian. I would not presume to second-guess your job, or armchair a military action. I don't have that expertise.
Military ops are quite different than civilian law enforcement ops. It is truly comparing apples and oranges. In the civilian world, both police and fire priorities are "Life over property". Any life, including that of suspects, is more important than any piece of property. That is the reality we live in. The mall would burn down before they would knowingly place responders in extraordinary danger (i.e. fighting fire with a possible IED in the area). That is very possibly different from the objective of a military operation.
Population
Sacramento City - 486,200
Roseville - 115,781
Roseville is not even 1/4 the size of Sac City
2) Crime Stats
Roseville - 2003 (maybe someone can find updated stats?)
Murder: 4
Forcible Rape: 22
Robbery: 68
Aggravated Assault: 172
Burglary: 572
Larceny or Theft: 2,650
Car Theft: 430
Arson: 10
Sac City - 2003
Murder: 43
Forcible Rape: 187
Robbery: 1,630
Aggravated Assault: 1,560
Burglary: 5,606
Larceny or Theft: 15,374
Car Theft: 7,286
Arson: 401
I'm not going to address city size and statistics. There are obvious differences in the two cities, and stats say what you want them to based upon context. That's not the point I'm trying to make.
1) A few annual training exercise PER YEAR does not mean a department is ready to handle that kind of situation. It takes experience and constant training.
I bet if you put an EOD team in there, it would have been taken care of A LOT faster...why is that? because thats all they train for...they did what they could with the experience and knowledge that they had. Was it horrible? NO...could it have had a better outcome if another department with more experience would have taken over? most likely.
The Roseville, Placer, and other local law EOD teams train much more often than "a couple times a year". When I was still there, they trained a minmum 1-2 times a month, sometimes more often, and it was true training, not seminars and reading books. They take their craft seriously. They have to, because they have to know that stuff in addition to their normal jobs. I don't know that the Sacramento teams train that much more. I honestly don't know. Would a military EOD team have handled it differently? Very likely. They have training and expertise that the civilian law enforcement bomb teams don't have.
The robot question was an honest question, NOT a bash...so no, it does NOT make a lie out of my statement...but take it however you want.
Since you are on the inside, lets ALL set our assumptions aside....Your one of the guys with the most legitimate information (No sarcasm, I'm being serious). Why would they need to turn off the water? And why did it take them so long to capture the guy?
My apologies on the robot comment. I took it differently than intended.
To clarify, I am not still actively employed at Roseville. I moved on to a job with the state several years ago, but maintain my local contacts. I do have additional information to clarify why it took so long to capture the suspect, but I haven't heard it come out publicly, and I am not going to be the one to do so. I am not involved in the investigation, so I don't know what is publicly releasable at this time. The decision to turn off the water was a tactical decision, and once again, I'm not going to second-guess it because I wasn't there. Would I have done it? Doubtful, but I don't know what information was available to them at the time.
I actually hope this is the last big post I make on this topic, because as an Admin I don't feel that I should be down in the trenches slinging mud. Unfortunately for you Blizzard, you are the recipient of a build-up of months of watching Roseville, Placer County, and the other small agencies get downtrodden in the forums by people who (based upon their comments) don't really know the facts they are talking about. I have not posted my opinion in the past, because everyone's entitled to their own, and my opinion is not likely to change anyone else's. But this incident has brought out the negativity, and I feel that something should be said.
Once again, you have my thanks and respect for your sacrifice. I would ask that those who are following this post also give the civilian police and fire personnel the respect they deserve for the jobs they do, wherever it is that they do it. Save the attacks, let the investigation run its course, and see what happens. Because I do know, if someone screwed up on that scene, Roseville will not sweep it under the rug. They will air their dirty laundry to avoid any controversy...believe me.